RSS Feed

The Lonely Witness by William Boyle

Amy was once a party girl, but she now lives a lonely life, helping the house-bound to receive communion in the Gravesend neighborhood of Brooklyn. She stops in at one of the apartments on her route, where Mrs. Epifanio, the elderly woman who lives there, says she hasn’t seen her usual caretaker, Diane, in a few days. Supposedly, Diane has the flu—or so Diane’s son Vincent said when he first dropped by and vanished into Mrs. E’s bedroom to do no-one-knows-what.


Amy’s brief interaction with Vincent in the apartment that day sets off warning bells, so she assures Mrs. E that she’ll find out what’s really going on with both him and his mother. She tails Vincent through Brooklyn, eventually following him and a mysterious man out of a local dive bar. At first, the men are only talking as they walk, but then, almost before Amy can register what has happened, Vincent is dead.

For reasons she can’t quite understand, Amy finds herself captivated by both the crime she witnessed and the murderer himself. She doesn’t call the cops to report what she’s seen. Instead, she collects the murder weapon from the sidewalk and soon finds herself on the trail of a killer.

Character-driven and evocative, The Lonely Witness brings Brooklyn to life in a way only a native can, and opens readers’ eyes to the harsh realities of crime and punishment on the city streets.


“Once a party girl, Amy now lives a solitary existence. This remarkable discordance is riveting, especially after Amy witnesses a murder and becomes at once traumatized by the crime and obsessed with the murderer. Amy elicits the same dark fascination as Sara Gran’s stellar neo-noir detective, Claire DeWitt. Boyle was featured in a Guardian write-up that compared him to Elmore Leonard and declared him a ‘new name to watch.’ That watching continues with this outstanding thriller.”
– Booklist

“Amy is the epitome of The Lonely Witness, William Boyle’s second character-driven novel that explores the neighborhoods of Brooklyn and the people who inhabit them. Boyle skillfully shows how crime fiction has the ability to explore what motivates people to choose their path in life. Boyle launched his gritty vision about this section of Brooklyn, where neighbors make their own small town, in his debut, Gravesend. The Lonely Witness offers an excellent sequel with a superb plot, matched by its realistically shaped characters.”
– Oline Cogdil, The Associated Press

“Powered by brilliantly realized characters, a richly described and grittily realistic backdrop, and subtle yet powerful imagery, this is crime fiction at its best: immersive, intense, and darkly illuminating.”
– Publishers Weekly

 “The Lonely Witness is a tense, and, at times, darkly funny, thriller. Reminiscent of writers from Daniel Fuchs to George Pelecanos, it’s safe to say that if you liked Gravesend, you’ll love The Lonely Witness. And if you haven’t read Gravesend, you will no doubt want to do so after reading The Lonely Witness.”
– Woody Haut, author of Pulp Culture, Neon Noire, Heartbreak & Vine

“Boyle is from Brooklyn, and his easy familiarity with this milieu shows up on virtually every page. If you like the richly nuanced novels of George Pelecanos or Dennis Lehane, be prepared to add Boyle to your regular reading list.”
– Bookpage

“The Lonely Witness is a map of Brooklyn’s genome. Amy Falconetti is that rarest of noir characters, a woman redeemed and a redeemer. Walking in her shoes for only a few blocks is worth the price of admission.”
– Reed Farrel Coleman New York Times bestselling author of ‘What You Break’

“A powerful, character-driven suspense novel that can keep you on the edge of your seat.” –  Popular Culture Association“In true noir fashion, William Boyle gives us an intimate portrait of a neighborhood in vivid, evocative prose, and explores how place and the past make us who we are. The Lonely Witness moves with unstoppable momentum, powered by Amy Falconetti’s impulsive human heart. I would gladly follow her anywhere.”
–  Melissa Ginsburg, author of ‘Sunset City’

“William Boyle has worked his way into becoming one of crime fiction’s talents. In both his short story collection and debut novel, he chronicles the battered souls of working class East Coast in a way that hits the heart without being maudlin. His second novel, The Lonely Witness, proves he is taking his skills further. What makes William Boyle’s work ring with such a strong and true voice is that he realizes for many daily life is a struggle. His writing prays for them.”
–  Mystery People (Pick of the Month)

“Boyle is a bard of Brooklyn.”
– Nick Mamatas, author of I Am Providence


Troubled woman in rut looking for way out of her neighbourhood but gets caught in whirlpool, a witness, a … , money tempting her, she cleaned up, people needed her, a parishioner, but some new things come to her realm, paternal figure tries to interlope her struggles. She’s not so used to have someone to call dad, as he has not been around making wrongs right, atonements.

A noir thriller that has this likeable main female character up against it trying to serve out a pipe dream and find her place in love, in credit, and free from the bonds that tie her to the past.

Nice writing in a gripping tale that keeps the reader on till the end with vested interests in one woman’s fate.